The Supreme Court sent a lawsuit over a fatal truck crash back to a California court on Nov 16. The lawsuit targets two companies that never drove the truck. Irigoyen Farms shipped the load, and Walmart was going to receive it.
Why it matters: If the family wins, a shipper could be held responsible for a crash by a trucker it never hired.
What happened: In September 2019, a truck ran a stop sign near Fresno, California, and hit a car. The car's driver, Olivia Mendoza, died at the scene.
The truck was carrying produce from Irigoyen Farms to a Walmart distribution center in Nevada. The truck driver, Andre Hill, was convicted of vehicular manslaughter and sentenced to two years in prison.
Irigoyen Farms did not hire Hill. According to court briefs, Irigoyen Farms hired a logistics company, Royal Violet Logistics. Royal Violet Logistics hired a second one, SIO Logistics. SIO Logistics hired a trucking company, Gold Coast Logistics, and Gold Coast Logistics hired Hill.
Mendoza's mother sued Irigoyen Farms and Walmart, along with others.
Why the case was thrown out: California courts dismissed Irigoyen Farms and Walmart before trial. The courts pointed to a federal trucking law, the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act, or FAAAA. It limits state lawsuits that affect a carrier's prices, routes or services. The courts said the law protected both companies.
Why it's back: In May, the Supreme Court ruled unanimously that the FAAAA does not protect freight brokers in crash cases. A broker can now be sued for being careless in picking a carrier. Lawyers call that a negligent selection claim.
The May ruling was about brokers. It said nothing about shippers or receivers. The Supreme Court has now told the California court to look at Irigoyen Farms and Walmart again.
What isn't decided: No court has said that shippers or receivers lose the law's protection. The Supreme Court did not answer that question in its order. The California court will take it up first.
What courts have looked at: In the cases so far, the question has been how involved the company was with the truck and the driver.
Walmart says it had no part in the trip. "Walmart did not select the broker, the motor carrier, or the driver," Walmart told the Supreme Court.
Irigoyen Farms was closer to it. Hill was at Irigoyen Farms' site, "where multiple people said he was visibly fatigued," said Gregory Reed, an attorney at Hanson Bridgett who follows the case.
Home Depot won a similar case in Texas in May. A Werner Enterprises truck carrying Home Depot freight was in a fatal crash, and the victim's family sued Home Depot too. The Texas Supreme Court dismissed Home Depot because it did not own the truck or supervise the driver.
Brokers show what is at stake. A Dallas County jury returned a verdict of about $604 million against CH Robinson over a 2021 crash by a carrier it hired. CH Robinson is appealing.
What's next: The California Court of Appeal takes the case up again. Walmart said it will keep defending itself there.
Photo: Walmart / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

















